Supreme Court strikes down Delhi HC order quashing registration granted
SENSEX 76,917.85 + 1,225.07 NIFTY 23,810.85 + 370.05 CRUDEOIL 9,238.00 + 166.00 GOLD 139,379.00 -807.00 SILVER 179,258.00 -4,521.00 SENSEX 76,917.85 + 1,225.07 NIFTY 23,810.85 + 370.05 NIFTY 23,810.85 + 370.05 CRUDEOIL 9…

+ 1,225.07
NIFTY 23,810.85+ 370.05
CRUDEOIL 9,238.00+ 166.00
GOLD 139,379.00-807.00
SILVER 179,258.00-4,521.00
SENSEX 76,917.85+ 1,225.07
NIFTY 23,810.85+ 370.05
NIFTY 23,810.85+ 370.05
CRUDEOIL 9,238.00+ 166.00
CRUDEOIL 9,238.00+ 166.00
GOLD 139,379.00-807.00
'; } document.getElementById("lgdv").innerHTML = htmlElements; } function numberformat(i) { return Number(parseFloat(i).toFixed(2)).toLocaleString('en', { minimumFractionDigits: 2 }) } async function gatherResponse(response) { const { headers } = response; const contentType = headers.get('content-type') || ''; if (contentType.includes('application/json')) { return await response.json() } return response.text(); } function getWidth() { if (Math.max(document.body.scrollWidth,document.documentElement.scrollWidth,document.body.offsetWidth,document.documentElement.offsetWidth,document.documentElement.clientWidth) > 991) { document.getElementById("mob").style.display = "none"; document.getElementById("lgdv").style.display = "block"; } else { document.getElementById("mob").style.display = "block"; document.getElementById("lgdv").style.display = "none"; } } getWidth(); THIS AD SUPPORTS OUR JOURNALISM. SUBSCRIBE FOR MINIMAL ADS.THIS AD SUPPORTS OUR JOURNALISM. SUBSCRIBE FOR MINIMAL ADS.Justices Sundresh and Varale uphold Crystal Crop Protection Ltd’s appeal against a division bench ruling of the the High Court in favour of Dhanuka Agritech
By BL Chennai Bureau
Updated - November 03, 2026 at 06:56 PM. | ChennaiCCPL was granted registration for the import and manufacture of Halosulfuran Methyl by the Registration Committee in July 2021. | Photo Credit: KK MUSTAFAH
The Supreme Court has struck down a Delhi High Court decision quashing the registration of a herbicide used to control weeds, granted to Crystal Crop Protection Ltd (CCPL) under the Insecticides Act, 1968.
Justices M M Sundresh and Prasanna B Varale passed the order on October 15 following an appeal from Delhi-based CCPL, which was granted registration for the import and manufacture of Halosulfuran Methyl by the Registration Committee in July 2021.
Halosulfan Methyl is a herbicide used in controlling nutgrass, purple nutsedge (Cyperus rotundus), and other sedges and broadleaf weeds in crops such as like sugarcane, maize, rice, bottle gourd, turfgrass, and ornamental landscapes.
Objection under Section 10, 11
Crystal Crop said it was granted the registration after testing by the Central Insecticides Laboratory and examination of the chemistry, bio-efficacy, toxicology and packaging data.
One of CCPL’s competitor, Dhanuka Agritech Ltd, objected to the registration before the Appellate Authority under Sections 10 and 11 of the Insecticides Act. However, its challenge was dismissed.
Following this, Dhanuka Agritech moved the Delhi High Court. A single judge upheld the Appellate Authority’s ruling. But following an appeal against the single judge order, a division bench quashed the registration granted to CCPL.
‘Exceeded limits’
Hence, the Delhi-based company chose to appeal in the Supreme Court. It argued that its product sample had been tested by the Central Insecticides Laboratory and found to have the claimed purity of 98.53 per cent.·
The Registration Committee examined the source verification issue in multiple meetings. It also produced agreements and documents establishing the linkage between the supplier and the original manufacturer.
The Registration Committee had accepted the explanations provided by the appellant before granting approval. It agreed that mandatory source verification had been completed satisfactorily.
The Supreme Court bench said the High Court exceeded its limits of judicial review by “effectively acting as an appellate authority”. It said judicial review over executive and technical decisions is limited, particularly where the decision involves grant of a regulatory licence after expert evaluation.
Section 10 provisions
The apex court also examined the maintainability of Dhanuka’s appeal under Section 10 of the Insecticides Act. It said Section 10 provides an appeal against decisions relating to non-registration or cancellation of registration, and not against the grant of registration to another person. Therefore, it cannot claim to be an “aggrieved person” entitled to challenge the grant of registration under Section 10, the judges said.
Justices Sundresh and Varale said where the Registration Committee has conducted detailed scrutiny, including testing, source verification, toxicological and bio-efficacy assessment, courts should ordinarily defer to the expert body’s findings “unless they are shown to be arbitrary or unlawful”.
Published on November 3, 2026
THIS AD SUPPORTS OUR JOURNALISM. SUBSCRIBE FOR MINIMAL ADS. THIS AD SUPPORTS OUR JOURNALISM. SUBSCRIBE FOR MINIMAL ADS. THIS AD SUPPORTS OUR JOURNALISM. SUBSCRIBE FOR MINIMAL ADS. THIS AD SUPPORTS OUR JOURNALISM. SUBSCRIBE FOR MINIMAL ADS.Sign into Unlock benefits!- Access 10 free stories per month
- Get notified by email for early preview to new features, discounts & offers
Figures reflect the source report and its stated period. This article is for information and is not investment advice.



